Landscaping Dispute Enters Year Two; Parties Agree Only That Grass Exists
Mediation efforts have stalled after both homeowners submitted competing expert opinions on the definition of 'lawn.'
By the Grounds Correspondent|Hobe Sound, FL — Nov. 19, 2026
What began as a neighborly disagreement over the precise boundary of a shared lawn edge has evolved into a 22-month administrative proceeding that has so far generated 340 pages of documentation and one formal request for a surveyor.
The dispute, between two residents whose properties share a 14-foot boundary along the eastern edge of the Mystic Cove common area, began in January 2025 when one party mowed what the other party described as "clearly my grass" and the first party described as "ambiguously situated turf."
Both parties have since retained landscape consultants. The consultants disagree not only on the boundary question but on the definition of the word "lawn," with one expert arguing that the disputed strip constitutes a transitional buffer zone and the other arguing that it is, in all meaningful respects, a lawn.
The HOA's Landscaping Subcommittee has met four times to consider the matter and has referred it to the full board twice. The full board has referred it back to the subcommittee once and to a newly formed ad hoc mediation panel once. The mediation panel has not yet convened.
Both residents declined to comment for this article. A neighbor who asked not to be identified said the grass in question "looks fine, honestly."